By Mister Curie
I have had several positive and affirming coming out experiences, including to my brother. I am now beginning to contemplate the best way to come out to my family so that it can be as positive an experience as possible. I would love some suggestions.
Here is the situation. We live far from the majority of my family and only visit once a year for 10-14 days, during which time we stay nearly exclusively at my parent's house. This trip typically occurs during the summer. Coming out is complicated by having two different issues to come out about: church disaffection and homosexuality.
Here are the pros and cons I have thought of so far for some of these parameters:
Coming out about both vs. only one issue
Pros for coming out about both:
complete honesty
get it over at one time
live authentically
overall response may be less protracted
Cons for coming out about both:
may confuse the two issues together
supports stereotype that homosexuality is sinful
might fail in making parents more understanding of homosexuals in general
minimizes my other issues with the church (which were not initially related to homosexuality and were sufficient to destroy my testimony without homosexuality being an issue)
response is likely to be stronger (if ultimately less protracted)
If choosing an issue: Church vs. Homosexuality
Pros for coming out about Church:
Follows time-line of my journey (this was the issue first)
Intellect and facts are on my side
If parents reject me over this issue, I can channel my frustration at the church
Pros for coming out about Homosexuality:
I think my parents would be more accepting of my homosexuality than disaffection
Disaffection may be more understandable coming from the perspective that I'm gay
Homosexuality can be seen as an innate quality, rather than a choice (such as drinking tea)
Wife and son would probably get sympathy and support
Cons for coming out about Church:
May make parents later think that homosexuality stemmed from Satan and sin
I think the response would be less favorable than for homosexuality
May estrange wife and son from my family
Blame may be placed on my wife
Cons for coming out about Homosexuality:
If rejected over homosexuality, I will feel like it is more of a personal rejection
Coming Out before visit vs. during visit
Pros for before visit:
If rejected, can save money by not purchasing plane tickets until we know response
less time hiding and more time feeling authentic
written letter will allow me to fully express thoughts without getting lost in emotional responses
things won't be as awkward if parents have time to process before we visit
Pros for during visit:
Will immediately have time in person to show I am the same person and rebuild relationship
More personal and intimate
If during visit: at beginning vs end of visit
Pros for beginning:
More time to show I am same person and to rebuild relationship
more time being authentic and less time hiding
Pros for end:
If bad response, won't be stuck with no place to stay
Less time for things to be awkward
What do you think? What considerations am I neglecting?